JapanCrate vs TokyoTreat: Which should I subscribe to?

    ※This site conducts advertising and promotional activities through affiliates.

    Update (September 2026): Japan Crate has closed

    Before reading this comparison, please note: as of September 28, 2026, the official Japan Crate website no longer sells boxes. Its homepage now shows a farewell message titled “Farewell from Japan Crate”, explaining that the company, which launched Japan Crate in 2014, has decided to focus on its other brands.

    The farewell page points readers to two sister brands: Bokksu, a Japanese snack subscription box, and Sugoi Mart, an anime and pop-culture shop with no monthly subscription.

    That changes the answer to “Japan Crate or Tokyo Treat?” Only Tokyo Treat can still be ordered, so this page now compares what Japan Crate used to offer with what Tokyo Treat offers today. Tokyo Treat details below are what we could check on its official site on September 28, 2026.

    Japan Crate vs TokyoTreat: Comparison Chart

    Japan CrateTokyoTreat
    StatusClosed (farewell page on the official site)Taking orders
    SnacksAnime and pop-culture themed Japanese snacks (while it was running)Full-size, Japan-exclusive snacks, candy and drinks
    PriceNo longer listed$37.5 (1 month) down to $32.5/month (12-month plan)
    Shipping to the U.S.—$16.99 per box, express/priority with tracking
    Allergen infoNo allergen list (while it was running)Complete allergen info and a 20-page booklet

    If you came here to choose between the two, the choice is now made for you: Tokyo Treat is the one you can subscribe to. The sections below explain how the two boxes differed, so you can tell whether Tokyo Treat, or another box, is the closest match to what you liked about Japan Crate.

    What Japan Crate offered (while it was running)

    Japan Crate was a monthly box of modern Japanese snacks. Its biggest feature was the theme: some months were built around anime and manga characters or Japanese subculture, and the box design changed with the theme, so the box itself was something fans liked to keep.

    The snacks were mainly candy, chocolate snacks, gummies and chips, plus a drink, and each box came with a small collectible item. Japan Crate did not list allergen or vegetarian information for its snacks.

    Because the official site no longer lists plans, prices or shipping rules, we have removed our old Japan Crate price and shipping tables rather than show numbers we can no longer confirm. For the full background, see our Japan Crate review.

    What TokyoTreat offers now

    Type of snacks in the box

    Tokyo Treat's subscribe page describes each box as full-size, Japan-exclusive snacks and candies. The categories it lists are:

    • Rare, Japan-exclusive and seasonal Kit Kat flavors
    • Cakes, cookies and breads such as melonpan and dorayaki
    • Japanese noodles such as ramen, soba, udon and miso soup
    • Hi-Chew and gummies
    • Chips and salty snacks
    • Japanese candies and chocolates such as Pocky
    • Seasonal Japanese drinks
    • Mochi and jellies

    This is close to the pop-snack side of Japan Crate: trending convenience-store snacks, candy and drinks rather than traditional wagashi. Tokyo Treat does not build its boxes around anime characters, though; its themes follow seasons and events, such as the Halloween box it was promoting when we checked.

    Price

    Tokyo Treat's regular plan prices on its official site (checked September 28, 2026) ↓

    PlanPrice per box (per month)
    12 months$32.5/mo
    6 months$33.5/mo
    3 months$35.5/mo
    1 month$37.5/mo

    The longer the plan, the lower the price per box. Tokyo Treat sometimes runs limited-time discounts on longer plans, so the price at checkout can be lower than this table. Shipping is charged on top of the box price.

    Shipping

    According to Tokyo Treat's shipping information page (last updated July 24, 2026), boxes to the United States go by express/priority shipping with tracking for $16.99 per box, with an estimated delivery time of 7 to 28 days after shipping. Rates and methods differ by country, so check the page for your country before ordering.

    Allergen information

    Tokyo Treat's subscribe page lists “Complete allergen info” and a 20-page booklet as part of every box. If you are buying for someone with food allergies, this was one area where Japan Crate fell short.

    Japan Crate vs Tokyo Treat|Which should you choose now?

    Japan Crate can no longer be ordered, so the practical question is which box replaces it.

    • If you loved Japan Crate's pop snacks, candy and drinks: Tokyo Treat is the closest match. It is taking orders, lists allergen information, and costs $37.5 for a single month.
    • If you want the box Japan Crate's own team points to: the farewell page recommends Bokksu. It focuses on traditional and regional snacks with a tea, so it is a different style from Japan Crate. See Japan Crate vs Bokksu.
    • If you mainly want anime and pop-culture goods: the farewell page points to Sugoi Mart, a shop with no monthly subscription.

    For most former Japan Crate subscribers who want a monthly box of modern Japanese snacks, we recommend starting with a one-month Tokyo Treat box.

    FAQ

    Can I still buy a Japan Crate box?

    No. As of September 28, 2026, japancrate.com shows only a farewell message and links to Bokksu and Sugoi Mart.

    How much does Tokyo Treat cost?

    On September 28, 2026, Tokyo Treat's regular prices were $37.5 for one month, $35.5 per month on a 3-month plan, $33.5 on a 6-month plan and $32.5 on a 12-month plan. Shipping is added at checkout; to the U.S. it is $16.99 per box according to Tokyo Treat's shipping information page.

    Is Tokyo Treat the same kind of box as Japan Crate?

    It is the closest in style: both focus on modern Japanese snacks, candy and drinks. Tokyo Treat's themes follow seasons and events rather than anime characters.

    Sources

    Please share!

    Site operator

    Japanese Snacks Samuraiのアバター Japanese Snacks Samurai

    A samurai who conveys the charm of Japanese snacks to the world. He is an ordinary university student living in Tokyo, Japan. His favorite sweets are Ottotto and Jagarico. He is a level 3 dietary advisor.